Week 43 of 2026 · Level 2 · 5×5 plan · Wild West town
Showdown
Copper Creek, the day the railroad came · The morning of the gold auction
Eli Washburn shod every horse in town and had overheard every argument that ever started at his forge. The undertaker found him at the undertaker's, and started measuring right away. Nobody has ridden out of town since. Everybody has a story, and one of them has more holes than a sieve.
The rules of this case
- Every row and every column holds exactly one person.
- People stand on open floor or sit on a chair. Nobody is on other furniture.
- The killer was the only other person in the victim's room.
Who was there, and what is known
- Eli Washburn · the victim, blacksmithCan bend a horseshoe with his bare hands. Bends the truth with even less effort.Was not next to any coffin.Was in the Undertaker's.
- Jedediah Stone · gold prospectorHas struck gold four times. Has lost it at cards four times.Was next to the jail cell.
- Horace Pettigrew · railroad manWants to run the railroad through the middle of town. Through the saloon, if possible.Was somewhere left of Eli.
- Prudence Whitaker · temperance campaignerHas smashed three hundred bottles of whiskey. Has never touched a drop. Not in public.Was sitting on a chair.
- Doc Elias Hooper · town doctorTreats everything with whiskey. Including himself.Was alone in a room.
The solution
Show the solution (spoiler)
In this order the clues place each person (the order the game's hints follow):
- Jedediah Stone: row 5, column 4, in the Sheriff's Office.
- Prudence Whitaker: row 3, column 5, in the Sheriff's Office.
- Horace Pettigrew: row 2, column 2, in the Undertaker's.
- Eli Washburn: row 1, column 3, in the Undertaker's.
- Doc Elias Hooper: row 4, column 1, in the General Store.
The killer: Horace Pettigrew, the only other person in the Undertaker's with Eli Washburn.
Horace did it. Eli owned the only strip of land the railroad could cross, and would not sell.