Week 45 of 2026 · Level 5 · 8×8 plan · Mansion
The Butler Didn't
Blackwood Manor, Yorkshire · Sunday luncheon
Mr. Julian Ferrars had come to value the Blackwood paintings and had put a price on everyone at dinner. The maid found him beside the writing desk just before the dinner gong. The storm has cut the telephone lines. Seven guests remain in the house, and every one of them had a reason.
The rules of this case
- Every row and every column holds exactly one person.
- People stand on open floor, sit on an armchair or stand on the rug. Nobody is on other furniture.
- The killer was the only other person in the victim's room.
Who was there, and what is known
- Mr. Julian Ferrars · the victim, art dealerCame to value the paintings. Has already sold two of them.Was next to the fireplace.Was next to the writing desk.
- Reverend Silas Sloane · the vicarPreaches forgiveness. Keeps a list.Was in the Kitchen.Was exactly two rows above Mr. Ferrars.
- Dr. Felix Crane · family physicianPrescribes brandy for everything, including brandy.Was next to the billiard table.Was alone in a room.
- Polly Brisket · the maidHas broken four vases this year and blamed the ghost every time.Was somewhere right of Mr. Ferrars.
- Mr. Cornelius Pinch · family solicitorHas read the will. Has also rewritten it.Was in the column directly right of Mr. Ferrars.
- Lady Agatha Blackwood · lady of the houseMarried for love. Of money.Was next to a suit of armor.Was alone in a room.
- Mortimer · the butlerForty years of service. Forty years of grudges.Was sitting on an armchair.
- Rupert Blackwood · the prodigal sonBack from the colonies. Nobody asked which ones.
The solution
Show the solution (spoiler)
In this order the clues place each person (the order the game's hints follow):
- Mr. Julian Ferrars: row 7, column 2, in the Study.
- Mortimer: row 3, column 5, in the Dining Room.
- Reverend Silas Sloane: row 5, column 4, in the Kitchen.
- Mr. Cornelius Pinch: row 8, column 3, in the Study.
- Lady Agatha Blackwood: row 4, column 7, in the Grand Hall.
- Polly Brisket: row 6, column 6, in the Long Gallery.
- Dr. Felix Crane: row 2, column 8, in the Billiard Room.
- Rupert Blackwood: row 1, column 1, in the Library.
The killer: Mr. Cornelius Pinch, the only other person in the Study with Mr. Julian Ferrars.
Mr. Pinch did it. Mr. Ferrars had noticed that the new will left everything to "C. Pinch, Esq." He has asked to represent himself.